site
Print-friendly version |

From my blog... by Sarah Clark



I've just been to see 'The Heartbreak Kid' and at the same time I saw the trailers for 'Good luck Chuck'

OK, I didn't expect them to be intellectual. But the Farrelly Brothers and their ilk really hate fat people, don't they? And I know 'Good luck Chuck' isn't a Farrelly production but it's following the same boring line.

If anyone's seen 'Shallow Hal' they will know what I mean. Let's all laugh at ugly fat people. Fat woman sits on chair and breaks it. Fat woman eats like a pig. Fat woman jumps in swimming pool and people run for cover. Oh ha-de-hah. That's so, like, ironic, yeah?

Of course it is. Shallow Hal was a crap film anyway, but the whole premise was that the leading man, Hal, no oil painting himself, was in love with a fat woman after being hypnotised into seeing her 'true beauty' - and when she was being beautiful he saw Gwyneth Paltrow without a fat suit - when he saw the REAL woman, he saw a fat pig (Gwynnie in a fat suit, how droll)

Yes, I know, it's a stupid film. But the whole genre just annoys me. In the Heartbreak Kid, there are two stand out 'laugh at the fat person' scenes - one where the new bride introduces the new groom to her mother - and the mother is fat. And the predictable joke is - 'I'm wearing her wedding dress...yes, the very same dress SHE wore.' As we all laugh heartily about the fact that women all turn into their mothers...and he's made a BIG mistake because the mother is fat (shock, horror)

The second is even worse - it's a fat CHILD joke. The woman that Ben Stiller's character falls in love with is enjoying taking Mexican children on fairground rides with her, on her lap. Ben joins in to impress her...and ends up with token fat kid. Oh, how we laughed.

As for the trailers to Good luck Chuck - not that I'm remotely tempted to see it anyway - the story is that Chuck gets jinxed by an ex - and every woman who sleeps with him marries her next boyfriend. So of course news gets out and lots of women want to sleep with him. Because we're all THAT desperate to get married that we'll have sex with a complete loser, aren't we girls?

So far so banal. Then he meets his *true love* and wants to break the curse. So he's got to find somebody that NOBODY will want to marry, huh?

Ohhhhh yes. Cue the appearance of the morbidly obese woman, having a good scratch, in a bikini on a sunlounger so we can all gawp at her true grotesqueness. If that wasn't bad enough, we switch to a shot of the pair out to dinner...and she is shovelling food in her gob like a woman possessed. With plenty of it down her chin, naturally.

Sorry, but are we to assume that if you are fat you automatically have disgusting table manners?

It just makes me angry. It's OK to stereotype fat people because it's plainly their fault, they deserve it, they are just there to be laughed at by crappy film makers who are stuck for anything genuinely funny to say...so they stick in a token fat person and make them disgusting-as-you-like.

Imagine if it were a disabled person we were poking fun at? An ethnic minority? Cue sharp intake of breath and howls of outrage. But if you are fat, you're fair game.

Check it out yourself and let me know what you think: www.youtube.com/watch?v=aEg4GQK5k7w

I'm pleased to say it scored highly on the Combustible Celluloid site:

Conspicuously absent from this romantic comedy are any genuine laughs or romance. The unfunny, uninteresting Charlie (Dane Cook) has been hexed: every girl he sleeps with is destined to next meet her true love. When he falls in love with Cam Wexler (Jessica Alba), he tries to break the spell. The makers of this shameful waste of celluloid have padded their work with fat jokes, homophobic jokes, gratuitous nudity and various bodily functions, while harbouring a fundamental hatred for women

Couldn't have put that better myself.

See Sarah's entry at www.freelancersintheuk.co.uk/products.php?productId=1351